Skip to content
"Those that criticize the Nationwide Monetary Prosecutor's Workplace have by no means defended the reform which might permit it to be impartial"

The Nationwide Monetary Prosecutor's Workplace (PNF), a judicial physique created underneath the presidency of François Hollande, is as we speak in turmoil following revelations about its administration in a number of circumstances. What function did he play within the Fillon, Kohler affairs? Is it impartial? How is it managed? Our journalist Simon Piel answered questions from Web customers of the World.

Article reserved for our subscribers Learn additionally Why the Nationwide Monetary Prosecutor's Workplace is in turmoil

Valentin: Why do the critics concentrate on the PNF, when it meets the identical necessities as a non-specialized prosecution, if not as a result of it disturbs political figures? If the PNF is to vary, ought to this not even be the case for your complete French public prosecutor's workplace?

Simon Piel: Critics as we speak concentrate on the PNF for a number of causes. The primary, for my part, is a short-sighted political expediency from the ranks of the politicians implicated. I like to recommend to you on this topic the discussion board revealed in The world by the lawyer and college professor Thomas Clay, who explains that the PNF is particularly the goal of these whom it disturbs, and factors out that moreover the political information this specialised parquet ground has many successes to be credited.

Widespread sense: François Fillon would have abused his standing as a deputy by making a detailed relative, his spouse, pay as a parliamentary assistant. Was this not the case for a major variety of parliamentarians?

Simon Piel: That is one in all his arguments. And evidently he was not solely improper. These nepotic practices seem to have been widespread for a few years. However Mr. Fillon is just not the one one to have been sentenced. For instance, former deputy Alain Marsaud was sentenced in 2018 to at least one 12 months suspended jail sentence, 300,000 euros high-quality and a three-year ineligibility sentence for fictitiously using his daughter as a parliamentary collaborator throughout 4 years.

Article reserved for our subscribers Learn additionally Within the Nationwide Meeting, the tough supervision of household jobs

Antigone: Isn't there a contradiction in contemplating that the stress for the opening of judicial info depends when, technically, it’s entrusted to "impartial" judges?

Simon Piel: This is among the most fascinating factors of this case. It needs to be remembered that François Fillon's legal professionals demanded the opening of judicial info, as a result of this was to permit an impartial investigating choose to take the lead and in protection of the previous Prime Minister of France. '' have entry to the process in the long run after which make requests for paperwork. The preliminary inquiry is secret and the defendants don’t have entry to it. The Fillon household’s counsel had expressed their satisfaction after the PNF press launch saying the opening of the judicial investigation.

What they didn’t foresee, maybe, was that the choose who was to be appointed was the Justice of the Peace Serge Tournaire, famend for his severity and diligence. It was the president of the Paris courtroom, Jean-Michel Hayat, reputed to be near the left, who selected the referral. For what causes ? The latter should even be heard by the parliamentary committee of inquiry, Thursday, July 2, and can most likely convey some solutions on the explanations for this alternative.

Manuel: Eric Ciotti needs to delete the PNF. Through which case, by which authority would it not get replaced? Does the argument made by the pro-PNF, saying that it’s essential to have judges who’ve information of questions linked to financing, does it maintain water?

It’s humorous to notice that each one those that as we speak criticize the Nationwide Monetary Prosecutor's Workplace have by no means defended the reform which might permit the prosecution to be impartial of the manager energy. This was neither in this system of François Fillon, nor in that of Jean-Luc Mélenchon. Everybody agrees {that a} specialised construction is required to cope with monetary crimes, that are generally very advanced. That is the aim of the PNF.

What may it’s changed with? I have no idea. Some audio system from the Parliamentary Fee of Inquiry on the Independence of Justice have put the thought of ​​a nationwide legal professional basic again on the desk. However right here once more, the query of controlling this authority will come up.

Learn additionally Eric Ciotti will desk a invoice to take away the Nationwide Monetary Prosecutor's Workplace

Laurent: Past the PNF, it’s the standing of the prosecution usually that’s at stake. For years we’ve got been ready for the reform of the Superior Council of the Magistrature which might give it its independence. No authorities has dared to launch this important reform.

That's proper. It was François Fillon's Les Républicains (LR) allies, now so fast to denounce the shortage of independence of prosecutors, who, within the spring of 2016, thwarted the constitutional reform undertaking supposed to ensure the appointment of magistrates. prosecution by the Keeper of the Seals solely after a assent from the Supreme Judicial Council (HJC).

This reform was content material to engrave within the Fundamental Regulation a follow revered for the reason that starting of the last decade 2010. Catherine Champrenault and Eliane Houlette have been appointed public prosecutor of Paris and public prosecutor of the Monetary Republic after an assent of the CSM. The constitutional reform can be a easy step in direction of extra independence of the prosecution from the federal government.

Clemclem: What’s the relationship between the Kohler affair, the letter that Emmanuel Macron despatched and the questioning of the PNF?

In response to info from the Anticor affiliation and the location Mediapart, the classification with out additional investigation of the preliminary investigation in opposition to the secretary basic of the Elysee, Alexis Kohler, accused of not having talked about his household ties with the Aponte household, the primary shareholder of the Italian sea freight operator Swiss Mediterranean Delivery Firm, occurred following the intervention of the President of the Republic. The protection of Mr. Kohler had certainly positioned within the file a notice signed by Emmanuel Macron, clearing, as a former minister of the economic system, his former chief of employees in Bercy from any battle of curiosity.

Nevertheless, the police famous in a abstract report that the investigation "Contained exact and constant components on the premise of which an investigating choose may have been seized and the examination of Mr. Kohler envisaged for the counts of unlawful acquisition of pursuits and buying and selling in affect".

Article reserved for our subscribers Learn additionally The investigation into Alexis Kohler relaunched by inspecting magistrates

MGridoux: The "pressures" exerted by the general public prosecutor's workplace on the PNF are solely requests for info accepted by judicial follow. The place is the issue ?

There are two issues. The primary is the suspicion that these calls for elevate in regards to the independence of the selections which were made. Bear in mind the Urvoas-Solère affair, which largely contributed to elevating suspicion in regards to the dangers of the judiciary being exploited by politicians. Jean-Jacques Urvoas, then Minister of Justice, had requested the directorate of felony affairs and pardons for a public motion sheet on the judicial investigation in opposition to LRM deputy Thierry Solère earlier than transmitting it by the encrypted Telegram utility.

These information had been skilled as a real betrayal by many magistrates, who had seen there a political instrumentalization of their companies and a deviation from the principles of knowledge suggestions, and for good cause. Jean-Jacques Urvoas has additionally been convicted earlier than the Courtroom of Justice of the Republic. The opposite downside, or reasonably the opposite query that arises in my view, is the relevance of this suggestions on political and monetary points.

Article reserved for our subscribers Learn additionally Fillon case: the previous monetary prosecutor evokes "huge stress" from his hierarchy